Enforcement is moving into the coffee sector

U.S. Customs and Border Protection issued its first import ban targeting the coffee sector earlier this year. This enforcement action signals that coffee companies can no longer treat forced labor as a remote legal concern. The EU Forced Labor Regulation will come into full force next year. These developments follow a global trend where governments enact human rights due diligence (HRDD) legislation to require companies to identify and address human rights risks in their supply chains. For coffee traders, roasters, brands, and retailers, these bans create immediate operational risks. A shipment linked to forced labor can be detained at the border, which disrupts supply and delays deliveries. Such interruptions cause lost sales, legal costs, compliance costs, and reputational harm. Companies also face scrutiny from investors, consumers, the press, and activists. I view these enforcement measures as an immediate requirement for companies to implement effective systems right now. Because a company needs credible evidence to challenge an import ban, it must show that goods were not produced with forced labor. It is impossible to build a viable HRDD system after a shipment is already detained. The need for a viable HRDD system is driven by the reality that a single detention can halt an entire supply chain. Companies must invest proactively to maintain market access and meet rising legal expectations. Governments expect companies to demonstrate what they are doing to manage risks. This means companies must have a way to identify and prevent serious labor abuses before they result in border detentions.

Traditional due diligence methods fall short

Traditional due diligence methods often fail to find real forced labor risks in extended supply chains. Many companies rely on superficial salience assessments, adverse-media scans, certifications, and supplier self-assessments to monitor their supply chains. These methods fall short in areas where government oversight is insufficient or civil society presence is weak. Certification inspections and traditional audits often miss forced labor because they do not include in-depth, confidential, off-site interviews with a representative cross-section of workers who can speak without fear of reprisal. These checks frequently miss specific indicators like deceptive recruitment, forced overtime, debt bondage, and wage and document retention. I find the industry’s heavy reliance on these inadequate tools to be a major weakness in current readiness. To fix this, buyers must build the capacity of traders, cooperatives, farmers, and distributors to detect and prevent risks. Buyers must also examine how their own purchasing practices, such as prices, delivery timelines, volume expectations, and production expectations, may exacerbate risks at the farm level. Buyers are responsible for providing their suppliers with practical tools and guidance. Effective risk detection requires worker-informed, field-based research that includes engagement with trusted local organizations. This research must focus on identifying the specific practices that result in forced labor. This work is a necessary component of a functioning due diligence process. I recommend using the Farm Labor Due Diligence Toolkit or the Cooperation On Fair, Free, Equitable Employment (COFFEE) Toolkit to start building these systems.

Spotted an error? Ask for a correction · Our editorial standards